Onboarding Importance Long

How Employers Drive Long Term Retention
Beyond the Introduction: How Employers Drive Long Term Retention
Date: July 2025
Produced by: Shayne Simpson

Recruitment agencies play an important role in connecting companies with the right talent. They are the initial spark that brings candidates to the table. But long-term retention is overwhelmingly shaped by the employer’s internal environment. Culture, onboarding, engagement, leadership, and career development determine whether new hires thrive and stay. Evidence from both academic research and practitioner studies shows that while agencies create the match, it is employers who sustain the relationship.

Bottom line: Agencies open the door. Employers create the reason to stay.

Introduction: The Retention Question

Recruitment often focuses on placements, but the real question is: what keeps employees beyond the first year? Agencies may secure strong matches, but retention depends on what happens inside the company. This paper synthesizes meta-analyses, CIPD and SHRM reports, Gallup studies, and HBR articles to demonstrate that employers bear the responsibility for long-term retention, not agencies.

The Employer’s Role: Sustaining the Flame

Organisational Culture

• SHRM research shows workers in positive cultures are almost 4x more likely to stay.
• Forbes highlights that shared values and purpose boost motivation and retention.
• CIPD data confirms UK employers cite culture and engagement challenges as central to retention.

Engagement and Leadership

• Gallup data links high engagement with productivity and loyalty.
• Regular weekly manager 1:1s and goal clarity are critical to retention.
• The maxim holds true: people leave managers, not jobs.

Selection Validity

• Structured interviews, job samples, and cognitive tests predict performance better than unstructured approaches.
• Agencies can advise, but employers own the design and execution of selection.

Onboarding as Retention Engine

• Organisations with standardized onboarding see 50% higher new hire retention.
• Pre-day-1 readiness, 30/60/90 plans, buddy systems, and manager check-ins drive early success.
• Poor onboarding is one of the fastest routes to early attrition.
• Career Development
• 94% of employees would stay longer if companies invested in their career growth.
• Employers must provide visible career paths, training budgets, and internal mobility opportunities.

The Agency’s Role – The Spark

Recruitment agencies contribute significantly at the start:

• Sourcing and matching: Identifying and vetting candidates with required skills and experience.
• Risk mitigation: Models like temp-to-perm reduce hiring risk.
• Access to talent pools: Agencies reach passive candidates not visible to employers.
• Expectation setting: Agencies provide market intel and shape candidate understanding.

Limitation: Once the hire is made, the agency’s influence declines sharply. Integration, engagement, and development belong to the employer.

Comparative Model: Agency vs. Employer Roles

---

Retention Ownership Model

Measurement and Accountability

Employers should track:

• 90-day attrition and first-year retention.
• Manager 1:1 cadence during the first 12 weeks.
• Onboarding completion index: equipment, systems, buddy, and plan readiness before day one.
• Time-to-productivity benchmarks.
• New hire eNPS at weeks 2, 6, and 12.
• Internal mobility rates in the first 24 months.

Practical Recommendations

For Employers:

• Invest in culture and belonging.
• Structure interviews and use realistic job previews (RJPs).
• Implement extended onboarding with manager ownership.
• Develop leaders with coaching and feedback skills.
• Provide transparent career paths and growth.
• For Agencies:
• Provide “warts and all” role expectation setting.
• Coach candidates on fit and motivators.
• Maintain warm pre-boarding communication.
• Advise employers on structured hiring practices.

Conclusion

Recruitment agencies are vital at the front door of talent acquisition. But long-term retention is driven by what happens after the candidate enters — culture, onboarding, leadership, and growth.
The evidence is clear: employers own retention.
Agencies introduce. Employers integrate.

References

• Sackett, P. R., Zhang, C., Berry, C. M., & Lievens, F. (2023). Revisiting the design of selection systems. Cambridge University Press.
• Schmidt, F. L., & Oh, I. S. (2016). Validity and utility of selection methods in personnel psychology. University of Baltimore.
• Earnest, D. R., Allen, D. G., & Landis, R. S. (2011). Mechanisms linking realistic job previews with turnover. Personnel Psychology.
• Bauer, T. N., & Erdogan, B. (2011). Organizational socialization: The effective onboarding of new employees. APA Handbook.
• Gallup (2025). U.S. Employee Engagement Sinks to 10-Year Low.
• SHRM (2024). Workplace Culture Fosters Employee Retention.
• Forbes (2024). How Your Company Culture Impacts Retention.
• HBR (2018). To Retain New Hires, Spend More Time Onboarding Them.
• HBR (2025). Don’t Lose Your Star New Hire.
• Apollo Technical (n.d.). 19 Employee Retention Statistics That Will Surprise You.
• CIPD (2024). Resourcing and Talent Planning Report.
• Work Institute (2024, 2025). Retention Reports.
• AIHR (2025). Employee Onboarding Statistics.

Prepared for leaders, clients, and partners seeking clarity on what actually drives long-term employee retention.